Intro

I’ve recruited across marketing, digital, PR and agencies for a long time, and one thing I’ve learned is that the market is rarely simply “good” or “bad”.

It’s usually just complicated.

And right now, that’s probably the best word for it.

There are still businesses hiring senior marketers. Current UK vacancies span CMOs, Marketing Directors, Heads of Marketing, Growth Directors, digital leaders and specialist roles.

But the conversations I’m having feel different.

Businesses are more cautious

I’m seeing more scrutiny around senior hires.

Not necessarily because businesses don’t want to invest.

Because they really don’t want to get it wrong.

Budgets are being challenged.

Headcount needs justification.

And somebody costing £80k, £100k or £120k+ needs to demonstrate why that investment makes commercial sense.

That’s not necessarily a bad thing.

But it changes how businesses should recruit.

The “perfect CV” problem

The danger is that caution turns into paralysis.

I’ve seen briefs become so specific that perfectly good candidates get ruled out because they haven’t worked in precisely the right sector, agency, business model or environment.

That’s understandable.

But there’s a difference between reducing hiring risk and trying to remove every possible element of risk.

You can’t.

Sometimes the safest-looking CV isn’t the best hire.

Senior marketers need to demonstrate commercial impact

At senior level, “I managed the marketing strategy” isn’t really enough anymore.

Businesses increasingly want to understand:

What grew?

What improved?

What did you change?

What did you personally own?

How did marketing affect the commercial performance of the business?

That means candidates need to be better at explaining their impact.

And businesses need to get better at assessing it.

AI is changing the mechanics, not the fundamental decision

Search is getting easier.

AI can help find people, analyse information, prepare questions and make recruitment processes more efficient.

Great.

I use it myself.

But that arguably makes the human bit more important.

Because finding somebody whose LinkedIn profile contains the right words isn’t the difficult part.

Working out whether they’re genuinely good is.

My view

I don’t think businesses have stopped hiring marketers.

I think they’ve become more deliberate about which marketing hires are genuinely worth making.

And personally, I think that’s healthy.

The businesses that get this right won’t necessarily be the ones interviewing the most people.

They’ll be the ones that are clearest about the problem they’re hiring somebody to solve.